He’s a Weird, Dorky Little Guy: Our Favorite Character Quirks on ‘Supernatural’

7 Min Read
The CW

Supernatural was such an intriguing show, both because of the endless and ever-building plot points and the complex and dynamic characters that viewers got to see fleshed out for 15 years. One of the best things about watching a show is getting to know a character and seeing them grow as more and more information about them is revealed — both directly and indirectly. Learning their idiosyncrasies, all of the little things that make them tick, helps paint a broader picture than the ones fleshed out in the story’s main narrative and those built to comprise the personalities you come to love so much. Today, we’re taking a look at some of our favorite quirks that helped us see a more complete picture in the characters of Supernatural.

Dean’s Appetite

The CW

Dean’s seemingly unending appetite and notoriously unhealthy diet (greasy spoons were his trademark) is a trait that manifested itself on-screen many a time. From The Elvis to a nice burger (or two if he was stealing Cas’) to the ever-sacred pie, you could always count on finding some food if Dean was nearby. How that man maintained his health was one of those cosmic mysteries that will never be solved.

Sam’s Serial Killer Obsession

The CW

You’d think after being around death his whole life; Sam Winchester would’ve steered clear of it in what little personal time he had to explore his interests. However, somewhere along the way in life, Samuel developed a wee obsession with serial killers (much to Dean’s bemusement). But, hey, who are we to judge? We all have that one friend who’s super into true crime.

Dean’s Cowboy Obsession

The CW

Sam calls it a fetish, and we’re not exactly sure that he was wrong. Whatever you want to call it, it was rare to see the older Winchester openly geek out about things, but cowboys was definitely one of them. Demonstrated in episodes like “Frontierland” and “Tombstone,” Dean lights up with a child-like glee anytime he gets to do or see anything related to the Old West. Heck, he even managed to drag Cas into a little getup. Dorky? Maybe. Adorable? Definitely. It’s a shame that we never got to see him wear those “Posse magnet” shirts he talked about.

Cas’ Music Taste

Jack and Cas FBI badges
Katie Yu/The CW

Cas — sweet, sweet Cas — took a page out of Sam and Dean’s book in using famous musicians’ names as aliases when working a case. Only, instead of rock gods, the sassy angel of the Lord seemed to have a proclivity for pop icons. From Agent Beyoncé to Agent Solange to Agent Lizzo, Cas’ choices of iconic black female musicians showed that he liked a little R&B and soul along with his Zep — and we love him for it. His … unique name choices did garner him quite a few raised eyebrows, though, which leads us right into our next one.

Cas Being Clueless

The CW

Though Castiel was definitely one of the most humanized celestial beings out there by the time season 15 rolled around; he still didn’t always manage to grasp the variety of subtle nuances of human behavior 24/7. This often left him hopelessly confused at times — especially when it came to references and expressions (ironic that he ended up with Dean as his best friend, huh?). Cas’ cluelessness quickly came to be one of his most adored traits by fans. How could it not with lines like “I assume it’s because seven is a prime number, and prime numbers can be intimidating…” and “You have a guinea pig? Where?” among others. Oh, Cas. Never change.

Sam’s Fear of Clowns

The CW

Coulrophobia, the fear of clowns, is one that Sammy boy knew well. The normally mild-mannered Winchester would immediately go stiff with fear any time one of these bad boys came around, sporting an alarming look like the one you see above. While we never found out exactly why he developed this fear (though we did know it started at Plucky Pennywhistle’s Magical Menagerie), it was definitely interesting to see that this — of all things is what made that young man tick.

Dean Being a Germaphobe

The CW

This is another one that’s funny simply because it’s so contradictory to the boys’ lifestyle. You’d think that growing up around blood and gore and dingy hotel rooms would disavow Dean’s germaphobic tendencies, but nope. In the smallest moments, the elder Winchester could be seen with a pinched expression on his face, studiously avoiding anything he deemed gross.

Jack’s Hello Hand

The CW

Jack’s adorably awkward wave became his character’s thing over the course of the show. Dean had pie, Sam had his hair, and this adorable toddler in a millennial’s body had his little wave. And we love him for it.

Dean’s Devotion to Baby

The WB

To quote Swayze, “Nobody puts Baby in a corner,” and Dean lived by that. Truly.

Seeing these small quirks and traits unfold on screen was a delight, as it gave greater insight into the complex and normally closed-off characters of Supernatural. The small glimpses of personality ultimately gave audiences a chance to see beyond the surface level, helping them connect to some of the greatest characters that television has ever seen, bolstering fans’ love for the little show that could.

Nerds and Beyond is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Share This Article
By Kenedi
Kenedi is a college student with her sights set on attending medical school. When she isn't hard at work, Kenedi enjoys reading, watching her favorite shows, and listening to music. Some of her favorite fandoms include Supernatural, One Tree Hill, Bones, Abbott Elementary, Percy Jackson, and Scrubs.
Leave a comment