Travis McElroy on Paranormal Podcast ‘Bigfoot Collector’s Club’

3 Min Read
Courtesy of Campfire Media

If you’re looking for a new paranormal podcast, you’re in luck!

Travis McElroy, the host of the podcasts My Brother, My Brother & Me, and The Adventure Zone, joins this week’s episode of comedic paranormal podcast Bigfoot Collectors Club to dish about all things paranormal.

Courtesy of Campfire Media

McElroy joins hosts Bryce Johnson (Pretty Little Liars) and Michael McMillian (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend) as they talk about everything weird that’s happened throughout history. The three start off by talking about the fun decorations Johnson and McMillian have throughout the studio, mentioning a giant yeti sculpture and books on the occult. The three then dish about Dungeons and Dragons, McElroy’s childhood, being born in West Virginia, and currently living in Cincinnati.

The three go on to converse about religion, Satan, and demonic possession. Johnson and McMillian ask McElroy about personal paranormal or weird encounters that he’s had. McElroy speaks about having an overactive imagination and being fascinated with cryptids; he actually has a Loch Ness Monster tattoo and a dog named Nessie. He mentions going ghost hunting in abandoned buildings when he was younger. He doesn’t quite believe in ghosts but admits he is open to believing in places having bad vibes and bad energy. McElroy tells the story of spending a weekend at Ravenwood Castle in Plymouth, Ohio, its murder mystery show, and seeing a werewolf in the woods.

The three then play a fun game named “believe it or bullshit” where the hosts give the guest a list of popular paranormal phenomena; the guests say if they “believe it” or call it “bullshit”. McElroy, Johnson, and McMillian go down the list and break down the things McElroy claims to believe in. They begin to discuss time travel – specifically a book named Time Travel in Einstein’s Universe and how time traveling could be actually possible. The three men end the show speaking on the possibility of bigfoot, or the “Mongolian Monster”, as a report of a firsthand encounter is read aloud.

Bigfoot Collectors Club is a Campfire Media production. New episodes hosted by Michael McMillian and Bryce Johnson come out every Wednesday on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Some of the show’s previous guests include comedian Jen Kirkman, Anna Camp (Pitch Perfect), Paul F. Tompkins (BoJack Horseman), Craig Ferguson, Rachel Bloom (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend), Joe Manganiello (Magic Mike), Scott Adsit (30 Rock), and so many more. This podcast is exceptionally enjoyable and is a must-listen if you are interested in the paranormal!

Nerds and Beyond is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to

Share This Article
Adrienne is a Certified Medical Assistant, as well as a new writer that joined the team in 2019. She is a lover of all things true crime, Supernatural, Sherlock, spoken word poetry, among others. You can find her on all her social media platforms under adri_lynn.
Leave a comment